As pet owners become more environmentally conscious, compostable poop bags are gaining popularity as a sustainable alternative to traditional plastic bags. These bags break down naturally, reducing landfill waste and minimizing your carbon footprint. But not all compostable bags are created equal—some are more durable, certified, and better suited for home composting than others.
If you’re looking to make a greener choice for your pet and the planet, we’ve rounded up the best compostable poop bags you can buy today. Let’s dig in!
Top 5 Best Compostable Poop Bags in 2025
1. Earth Rated Compostable Dog Poop Bags
Earth Rated is a trusted brand among pet owners, known for its durable and eco-friendly poop bags. Their compostable option is BPI-certified, ensuring it meets industry standards for biodegradability.
✅ Pros:
-
Certified compostable (OK Compost & BPI)
-
Scented with lavender to mask odors
-
Extra thick and leak-proof
-
Affordable and widely available
❌ Cons:
-
Not suitable for home composting (requires industrial facilities)
2. Cuddle Snuggle Compostable Dog Poop
The cuddle snuggle compostable dog poop bags are 100% COMPOSTABLE & BIODEGRADABLE: Made from 100% plant-based materials, there pet poop bags break down naturally in composting environments, helping reduce landfill waste, making them a responsible choice for environmentally-conscious pet owners.
✅ Pros:
- Made from 100% plant-based materials
- Designed for maximum durability
- Easy to use
3. BarkButler X Fofos Poop Bag Refills
Made out of a resin derived from plants, vegetable oils and compostable polymers, and break down completely in the right conditions (under 18 months). These bags are the perfect for dogs.
✅ Pros:
- Made from the plants, vegetable oils and compostable polymer
- Thicker than standard bags, reducing the risk of tears and leaks.
- Made from plant-based materials, reducing plastic pollution.
- Some variants include odor-neutralizing scents. Easy to refill and fits standard poop bag holders.
❌ Cons:
- Requires industrial composting facilities (not suitable for backyard compost bins).
- Unscented version may not mask odors as effectively.
4. PoopBags.com Compostable Bags
PoopBags.com offers budget-friendly, BPI-certified compostable bags that balance affordability and sustainability. While not as thick as premium brands, they get the job done for everyday use.
✅ Pros:
-
BPI-certified compostable
-
Extra-large size for bigger dogs
-
Affordable bulk options
❌ Cons:
-
Not as sturdy as premium brands
Comparison table
| Brand | Certifications | Materials | Scented | Home Compostable | Key Pros | Cons | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Earth Rated | OK Compost, BPI | Plant-based | Yes (Lavender) | No | ✔ Thick and leak-proof ✔ Widely available ✔ Certified compostable |
❌ Not for home compost ❌ Industrial facility needed |
Buy Now |
| Cuddle Snuggle | 100% Compostable | 100% Plant-based | No | Yes | ✔ Fully biodegradable ✔ Durable ✔ Easy to use |
❌ Limited availability | Buy Now |
| BarkButler X Fofos | Industrial Compost | Resin, vegetable oils, polymers | Some variants | No | ✔ Strong and thick ✔ Reduces plastic pollution ✔ Fits all holders |
❌ Not home compostable ❌ Unscented version lacks odor control |
Buy Now |
| PoopBags.com | BPI Certified | Cornstarch Blend | No | No | ✔ Budget-friendly ✔ Extra-large for big dogs ✔ Compostable |
❌ Less durable than others | Buy Now |